You can tell an actor is on a roll when he is cast as Christ and a merciless killer in the course of a single season. After his idiosyncratic Jesus in Mary Magdalene (see review below), Joaquin Phoenix rises again as Joe, the world-weary assassin of You Were Never Really Here (★★, 15, 85 mins), director Lynne Ramsay’s take on Jonathan Ames’s novel.
Bulked out and hoodied-up, Phoenix is the centrepiece of a violent jigsaw puzzle bearing edges so sharp they could take your eye out. Ramsay’s New York bloodbath has been drawing comparisons to Martin Scorsese’s landmark Taxi Driver, yet the most apt review perhaps lies in wait among a police bulletin’s final lines: approach with caution, if at all.
A dishevelled hulk of scar tissue held together by muscle memories of some still-vivid trauma, Joe spends his lonely downtime pondering how to end his torment: his hobby would appear to be sticking his head in plastic bags. As for his uptime, all we need to observe is the way he eyes the ball-peen hammers in his local hardware store.
Not for this thug the clean kills of a silenced gun; his tendency to absent himself from rooms, conversations and normal society stems from an awareness that no good can come from his being around. Even when he gains renewed purpose – undertaking to rescue a girl from a child sex ring – we can only fear the worst.
Everything about the film has been designed to make its audience flinch. As 2011’s We Need to Talk About Kevin suggested, Ramsay has become increasingly fascinated by the evil that men do, and increasingly forceful in her methods of putting that evil across. When Joe squishes a jellybean between his fingers, it registers as if a planet had been vaporised, so you can imagine the impact when somebody’s brains get blown out.
There’s skill behind the shock tactics – Joe Bini’s editing sublimates the worst exploitation – but I felt that Ramsay was pursuing this vision of dead-end masculinity into a creative dead end of her own. Not even her thoroughly committed star could sell me on Joe’s late and phoney-seeming redemption.
How to continue reading…
This article appears in the Catholic Herald magazine - to read it in full subscribe to our digital edition from just 30p a week
The Catholic Herald is your essential weekly guide to the Catholic world; latest news, incisive opinion, expert analysis and spiritual reflection